Tue, 29 Mar 2011 20:04:34 +0200
Rework package yet again, correcting and introducing new buildconf logic:
Conditionally disable bootstrap stage comparison correctly, correct
english grammar, better find system as(1) and ld(1), indotruce detailed
optimization option messages, more completely guess cpu types, allow
profiled bootstrapping without a preinstalled GCC because many other
compilers have long since implemented 64-bit arithmetic, instruct make
to build sequentially (not in sparallel) when building a profiled
bootstrap as GCC online documents recommend, and generally improve
comment blocks.
The single most important correction in this changeset relates to the
GCC changed optimization policy since at least GCC 4.5, in which -march
is always passed and not always correctly guessed. In the case of this
package, allowing GCC to guess the architecture leads to wild build
errors at various subcomponents (zlib, libgcc, libiberty...) and
bootstrap stages. It seems quite platform specific, and the safest
approach to correcting this seems to be explicitly always specifying the
-march argument when bootstrapping GCC. Because the best choice 'native'
is not available when bootstrapping using a foreign (non GCC) compiler,
a guess is made according to rpmmacros l_platform in that case.
It is questionable as to whether these recent optimization changes
on the part of GCC or this package are compatible with each other,
or if either are complete or correct at all. At least applying these
corrections allows this package to build again in most cases test.
gcc/gcc.spec | file | annotate | diff | comparison | revisions |
1.1 --- a/gcc/gcc.spec Tue Mar 29 19:46:35 2011 +0200 1.2 +++ b/gcc/gcc.spec Tue Mar 29 20:04:34 2011 +0200 1.3 @@ -131,8 +131,11 @@ 1.4 -e 's;(libdir)/gcc/;(libdir)/gcc%{V_comp}/;' \ 1.5 `find . -name Makefile.in -type f -print` 1.6 fi 1.7 + %{l_shtool} subst \ 1.8 + -e 's;^\(do-compare\) *\(=.*\);#\1-shouldnt-be-defined-here \2;' \ 1.9 + config/*.mk 1.10 case "%{l_platform -t}" in 1.11 - amd64*-linux* ) 1.12 + amd64-linux* ) 1.13 %{l_shtool} subst \ 1.14 -e 's/GLIBCXX_IS_NATIVE=false/GLIBCXX_IS_NATIVE=true/g' \ 1.15 -e 's/test x.gcc_no_link = xyes/false/g' \ 1.16 @@ -144,21 +147,19 @@ 1.17 libstdc++-v3/include/ext/codecvt_specializations.h 1.18 1.19 %build 1.20 - # create build sub-directory 1.21 + # create build subdirectory 1.22 %{l_shtool} mkdir -p obj 1.23 cd obj 1.24 1.25 - # solve strange compatability problems 1.26 + # locate ld(1) and as(1) accordingly 1.27 %if "%{with_binutils}" == "yes" 1.28 - # determine ld(1) and as(1) usage, allowing either 1.29 - # one to be from the GNU distribution of binutils 1.30 + # allow OpenPKG binutils 1.31 LD=%{l_tool_locate ld ld} 1.32 AS=%{l_tool_locate as as} 1.33 %else 1.34 - # locate ld(1) and as(1), using the GNU assembler 1.35 - # but ignoring the presence of any OpenPKG linker 1.36 - LD=`PATH=/bin:/sbin:/usr/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/ccs/bin:/opt/bin:/opt/sbin which ld` 1.37 - AS=`PATH=/bin:/sbin:/usr/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/ccs/bin:/opt/bin:/opt/sbin which as` 1.38 + # ignore OpenPKG binutils 1.39 + LD=`PATH=/bin:/sbin:/usr/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/ccs/bin:/opt/bin:/opt/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/local/sbin which ld` 1.40 + AS=`PATH=/bin:/sbin:/usr/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/ccs/bin:/opt/bin:/opt/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/local/sbin which as` 1.41 %endif 1.42 l_with_gnu_ld_as="" 1.43 echo $LD | grep '^/' >/dev/null && l_with_gnu_ld_as="--with-ld=$LD" 1.44 @@ -166,14 +167,14 @@ 1.45 $LD --version </dev/null 2>/dev/null | grep "^GNU ld " >/dev/null && l_with_gnu_ld_as="${l_with_gnu_ld_as} --with-gnu-ld" || l_with_gnu_ld_as="${l_with_gnu_ld_as} --without-gnu-ld" 1.46 $AS --version </dev/null 2>/dev/null | grep "^GNU assembler " >/dev/null && l_with_gnu_ld_as="${l_with_gnu_ld_as} --with-gnu-as" || l_with_gnu_ld_as="${l_with_gnu_ld_as} --without-gnu-as" 1.47 1.48 - # determine threads usage 1.49 + # determine threads use 1.50 %if "%{with_threads}" == "yes" 1.51 l_enable_threads="posix" 1.52 %else 1.53 l_enable_threads="single" 1.54 %endif 1.55 1.56 - # determine language usage 1.57 + # determine language use 1.58 l_enable_languages="c" 1.59 %if "%{with_cxx}" == "yes" 1.60 l_enable_languages="${l_enable_languages},c++" 1.61 @@ -188,14 +189,14 @@ 1.62 l_enable_languages="${l_enable_languages},f95" 1.63 %endif 1.64 1.65 - # disable GNU iconv usage 1.66 + # disable GNU iconv use 1.67 ( echo "am_cv_func_iconv=no" 1.68 echo "am_cv_lib_iconv=no" 1.69 ) >config.cache 1.70 - 1.71 - # platform specific config logic 1.72 + # platforms failing 'compare' make target (see prep as well) 1.73 case "%{l_platform -t}" in 1.74 - *i?86-sunos* ) echo "gcc_cv_prog_cmp_skip=true" >>config.cache;; 1.75 + *i?86-sunos* ) echo "gcc_cv_prog_cmp_skip=true" >>config.cache ;; 1.76 + *amd64-linux* ) echo "gcc_cv_prog_cmp_skip=true" >>config.cache ;; 1.77 esac 1.78 1.79 # configure the package 1.80 @@ -259,50 +260,67 @@ 1.81 l_libcxxflags="$l_libcxxflags -pipe" 1.82 } 1.83 %if "%{with_optimize}" == "yes" 1.84 + # GCC authors are not keeping up with optimized portability expectations 1.85 + ( echo "As GCC advances its optimization logic becomes increasingly complex (and" 1.86 + echo "buggy?) Since at least GCC 4.5, problems have been reported using arguments" 1.87 + echo "-O, -mtune, or -march implicitly or explicitly during different bootstrap" 1.88 + echo "stages as well as stage comparison and even the final installation." 1.89 + echo "" 1.90 + echo "Pay attention when building on one computer and installing on another as" 1.91 + echo "problems may be platform specific. If in doubt, disable optimization." 1.92 + ) | %{l_rpmtool} msg -b -t warn 1.93 if [ ".$l_ccisgcc" = .yes ]; then 1.94 - l_ia32=native 1.95 + l_archia32=native; l_archia64=native; l_archamd64=native 1.96 else 1.97 - l_ia32=pentium3 1.98 + # CPU native detection only works with GCC (see driver-i386.c) 1.99 + ( echo "Platform specific optimization is enabled, but detection of appropriate" 1.100 + echo "native architecture is only possible when bootstrapping GCC using a pre-" 1.101 + echo "installed GCC. The current build is using a different compiler, so to" 1.102 + echo "provide any optimization at all a wild guess is made and a CPU type" 1.103 + echo "hardcoded instead of using accurate native detection." 1.104 + echo "" 1.105 + echo "To achieve accurate optimization of GCC please install GCC first. Then" 1.106 + echo "build this package a second time which will use GCC to bootstrap itself." 1.107 + ) | %{l_rpmtool} msg -b -t notice 1.108 + 1.109 + # guess lowest common denominator CPU types 1.110 + # http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/(X86|X64-64) 1.111 + # http://gcc.gnu.org/onlinedocs/gcc/i386-and-x86_002d64-Options.html 1.112 + l_archia32=pentium3; l_archia64=nocona; l_archamd64=k8 1.113 fi 1.114 + # this optimization logic is unportable and could cause problems 1.115 + # if installing the resulting binary package on a different host! 1.116 case "%{l_platform -t}" in 1.117 - *i?86-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -mtune=$l_ia32" ;; 1.118 *sun4[uv]-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -mtune=v9" ;; 1.119 + *sun-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -mtune=v8" ;; 1.120 + *i?86-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -march=$l_archia32" ;; 1.121 + *ia64-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -march=$l_archia64" ;; 1.122 + *amd64-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -march=$l_archamd64" ;; 1.123 + * ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -mtune=generic" ;; 1.124 esac 1.125 l_cflags="$l_cflags -O" 1.126 l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -O3 -fomit-frame-pointer" 1.127 l_libcxxflags="$l_libcxxflags -O3 -fno-implicit-templates" 1.128 %else 1.129 -%if "%{with_optimize}" == "port" 1.130 - # conservatively optimize the generated program code for portable use, 1.131 - # also _tune_ for particular CPUs, but _without_ requiring these CPUs! 1.132 - case "%{l_platform -t}" in 1.133 - *i?86-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -mtune=generic" ;; 1.134 - *sun4[uv]-* ) l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -mtune=v8" ;; 1.135 - esac 1.136 - l_cflags="$l_cflags -O" 1.137 - l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -O2 -fomit-frame-pointer" 1.138 - l_libcxxflags="$l_libcxxflags -O2 -fno-implicit-templates" 1.139 -%else 1.140 - # do not optimize at all to avoid problems 1.141 + # don't optimize at all to avoid problems 1.142 l_boot_cflags="$l_boot_cflags -O0" 1.143 l_libcxxflags="$l_libcxxflags -O0" 1.144 %endif 1.145 -%endif 1.146 +%if "%{with_profile}" == "yes" 1.147 + maketarget="profiledbootstrap" 1.148 + loc_makeflags="%{l_mflags}" 1.149 + if [ ".$l_ccisgcc" != .yes ]; then 1.150 + ( echo "A preinstalled GCC is recommended when bootstrapping a profiled GCC. If the" 1.151 + echo "compiler used to bootstrap GCC doesn't support 64-bit arithmetic, then" 1.152 + echo "either runtime or buildtime errors could occur. Regardless of this," 1.153 + echo "parallel make logic is disabled according to profiling requirements." 1.154 + echo "" 1.155 + echo "If in doubt, stop now and start the build again with profiling disabled." 1.156 + ) | %{l_rpmtool} msg -b -t warn 1.157 + fi 1.158 +%else 1.159 maketarget="bootstrap" 1.160 -%if "%{with_profile}" == "yes" 1.161 - # GCC >= 3.4 supports a "profiledbootstrap" target to build an 1.162 - # optimized version of itself through profiling. Because this 1.163 - # requires a (bootstrapping) C compiler with 64-bit arithmetic, 1.164 - # the whole approach is currently supported only if already 1.165 - # building with GCC as the bootstrapping C compiler. 1.166 - if [ ".$l_ccisgcc" = .yes ]; then 1.167 - maketarget="profiledbootstrap" 1.168 - else 1.169 - ( echo "Building a profiled GCC requires GCC. Please install GCC" 1.170 - echo "first and then build again with the profile option enabled." 1.171 - ) | %{l_rpmtool} msg -b -t error 1.172 - exit 1 1.173 - fi 1.174 + loc_makeflags="%{l_mflags -O}" 1.175 %endif 1.176 case "%{l_platform -t}" in 1.177 *64-* ) l_cflags="$l_cflags -fPIC"; l_cxxflags="$l_cxxflags -fPIC" ;; 1.178 @@ -315,10 +333,10 @@ 1.179 %endif 1.180 1.181 # build the package 1.182 - MAKE="%{l_make} %{l_mflags -O}" \ 1.183 - %{l_make} %{l_mflags -O} \ 1.184 + MAKE="%{l_make} ${loc_makeflags}" \ 1.185 + %{l_make} ${loc_makeflags} \ 1.186 GREP="grep" \ 1.187 - MAKE="%{l_make} %{l_mflags -O}" \ 1.188 + MAKE="%{l_make} ${loc_makeflags}" \ 1.189 BOOT_CFLAGS="${l_boot_cflags}" \ 1.190 CFLAGS="${l_cflags}" \ 1.191 CXXFLAGS="${l_cxxflags}" \